I have killed over 40 bull alligators now and not found a single skin. Passing time and just being thourough, I've killed well over 100 other alligators as well. All this just in Innothule swamp. I'm not even counting gators in other zones that I've hunted on the off chance they may drop the skin.
I see several people saying that, while somewhat rare to come by, they have found skins. I see several more people saying that they have hunted for hours on end with no sign of them. Is it possible that certain servers are bugged and simply don't drop the skin?
FWIW I play on Mith Marr and have yet to see a skin. Nor has anyone in any zone I've auctions/ooc/shouted that I will buy them even admitted to finding one. Unless its no drop, I would have expected at least one person to have it banked simply knowing how rare they were, but not a single person I've come across seems to have found one.
Muddletupper