Quote:
Anyone who has played a tank knows that a Sucessful Taunt dose not always result in the mob attacking you. A common example is when breaking mez and the chanter is sitting. Even with the sucessful taunt the mob will attacking the sitting chanter first.
Look back at the linked post I gave earlier. It doesn't say it sends you to the top of the aggro list, it sends you to the top of the hate list. Aggro is more than hate. Things like sitting down near the mob, being the puller, and other actions give you a "hate bonus" that taunt may or may not over come, depending on the bonus. If the bonus is small, taunt can overcome it, if the bonus is large, then maybe not.
Quote:
Furthermore I and others have noted that mashing taunt will give you agro lock when with out mashing taunt you get ping pong agro.
In actual combat, many things are going on besides taunt. There are going to be cases where ping pong aggro results from using taunt and cases where it will not. Mashing the button may or may not be making a difference in holding aggro in those cases where it has appeared it has. And at the high end game, where so much is going on, mashing the button won't make a difference at all. At the link I made above at the warrior board, as well as similar results from paladins, SKs, and rangers, as well as that post from the developer, mashing does very little to help you.
Note:Whether or not the developer who made the comment has actually played a tank, that original post by the developer was made back when SoE had decent customer service and actually talked to developers who HAVE played the class before saying things.
Quote:
For me in game observations trump theroy.
Yes it does, but you need to make complete observations, with experimentation in a controled setting, such as those who did the experiments that I posted did. There are MULTIPLE folks who have posted at steelwarrior and other places saying taunt works one way with hard data and experiements to back it up, and then there is just you supporting your version, with nothing to back up your claims. There is a reason why the most go with the "common belief" approach to taunt.
Edited, Sun Oct 17 10:13:41 2004 by dfrnchman